The ONE Critical Mistake To Avoid As An Investment Property Owner

Ryan Jamison • March 14, 2024

Any property owner with a pulse knows that they have to keep their property insured. That said, many investment property owners fail to realize that they need a specific type of insurance policy for their rental property.  As an investment property owner, you MUST get a Landlord insurance policy, rather than a normal Owner-Occupant insurance policy.


Understanding the distinction between a Landlord policy and an Owner-Occupied policy is critical to ensuring that, in the event of a claim, the investment property owner is adequately insured. In fact, any claim for property damage to an investment property made under an owner-occupant insurance policy will surely be denied.  Insurance companies LOVE denying otherwise legitimate claims on policy coverage basis, and making sure that you have the right type of insurance policy in place is critical!


Briefly discussed below are the two primary situations in which an investment property owner finds themselves improperly insured:


  1. Primary Residence conversion to Rental:  This situation most often occurs when an Owner Occupant purchases a new home to live in and, rather than sell their previous home, the owner converts their old primary residence into an investment property.  Undoubtedly, this form of “house hacking” is an excellent way to build a real estate portfolio (purchasing a primary residence offers advantages as to down payment amounts, optimized interest rates, etc.), but the owner MUST notify their insurance carrier about the change of status of the original home from owner-occupied to investment property, or future claims will be denied on that basis. Often, this critical step gets lost in the chaos of the new home purchase and move!
  2. Primary Residence as an occasional Short Term Rental:  Understandably, many owner occupants are interested in generating ancillary revenue from their homes. To that end, homeowners may list their homes on various vacation rental websites, particularly during major music festivals and/or sporting events in their area, in order to take advantage of the influx of tourists.  This can be a major problem in the event of an insurance claim, in that most owner-occupant insurance policies have specific coverage exclusions for short term rentals and vacation rentals. Insurance claims on properties that are used as vacation rentals, even if the claim is unrelated to the vacation rental (i.e. hail damage), can be denied on the policy coverage basis.


So what’s the takeaway here? The TYPE of insurance policy required is dictated by the USE of the property. Make sure you are clearly communicating with your insurance agent about the use of your property, to make sure that future claims are covered!




Thanks for reading, hope this was helpful. Talk soon!

By Claudia Flores January 6, 2026
Discover common costs of hiring a residential property manager. We break down monthly fees and leasing costs to help you maximize your rental investment.
By Claudia Flores January 6, 2026
Discover how Good Neighbor Property Management provides the best property management in Austin. Learn how our residential management strategies maximize ROI.
By Claudia Flores November 26, 2025
Duplexes are a fantastic way to invest in Austin's booming real estate market, offering two income streams on one piece of land. However, managing these properties presents a unique set of challenges that differ significantly from single-family rentals. Good Neighbor Property Management understands the specific demands of these two-unit structures and offers tailored expertise to maximize your return and minimize your stress. Shared Space and Maintenance Coordination
By Claudia Flores November 25, 2025
How Good Neighbor Property Management Supports Long-Distance Landlords
October 6, 2025
First-time landlord? Learn the essentials of Austin Texas property management. Good Neighbor Property Management offers peace of mind and local expertise.
By Claudia Flores September 10, 2025
Entrusting your investment property to a management company is a significant decision. The right partnership can maximize your returns and minimize stress, while the wrong one can lead to costly vacancies and headaches. To make a confident choice, it's crucial to evaluate potential partners based on a few key criteria that define a top-tier service.
August 21, 2025
When selecting a partner to manage your rental property, the choice often comes down to a large national firm or a dedicated local expert. While both have their place, a local company offers distinct advantages that directly impact your investment's success. We believe that proximity and community insight are foundational to exceptional residential property management.
New to property investment? Learn what to look for in a property manager, from transparent pricing t
By Claudia Flores July 23, 2025
Navigating the world of rental properties can be complex, especially for new owners. Hiring a property manager can alleviate much of this burden, but understanding what to look for is crucial. This guide will help you make an informed decision.
By Claudia Flores June 24, 2025
As a property owner, the success of your investment hinges on the quality of your tenants. Understanding the significance of tenant screening and background checks is crucial for maintaining your property and ensuring timely rent payments. Hiring a rental management company like Good Neighbor Property Management can take this essential process off your hands, providing peace of mind and financial security.
Model home and keys on top of a clipboard
By Claudia Flores May 22, 2025
Learn how Good Neighbor Property Management helps landlords stay compliant with legal requirements and regulations. Reach out today!
More Posts